Journal/Playbook

Twenty-eight days

A complaint notice lands on a Thursday in November: four items, photos, dates. Under Victoria’s new home warranty the builder has 28 days, and what happens in them is the whole defence. What happens after is damage control.

A two-colour risograph poster of a four-week calendar grid drawn like a plan, the last cell hatched orange
WP
Will PrinmanCo-founder
9 November 2026·5 min read

The email arrives on a Thursday afternoon in November 2027. It is a complaint notice under the home warranty scheme that started in July 2026, from the owners of a single-storey house in Ocean Grove you signed up in August 2026 and handed over in March. Four items: a crack in the ensuite floor tile, a sticking sliding door to the deck, a downpipe discharging onto the slab edge, and "water staining on the laundry ceiling, noticed in October". There are photos. There is a date for each.

You now have 28 days to respond. Not 28 business days, and not 28 days from when you get around to opening it. 28 days from receipt, with 22 December to 10 January not counted, which in November is no help at all.

If you do nothing useful in those 28 days, the owners take it to the Building and Plumbing Commission. The Commission assesses it, usually sends an inspector, and if it finds the work defective it usually issues a rectification order. Orders go on the public register. The warranty pays the owners if you do not comply, and the Commission comes after you for the cost.

The 28 days are the whole defence

That is my view, and it is the point of this post. Under the old insurance, an owner with a trading builder had dispute resolution and then VCAT, and the builder had a year to think. Now the four weeks after the notice lands are where the builder either settles the matter or hands it to a regulator. What you do in them is the defence. What you do afterwards is damage control.

And four weeks is not long. It is a site visit you have to fit in, a trade you have to find who left in April, a decision on each item, and a letter. On a busy month that is day 26 before anyone notices.

What the four weeks should look like

Day one, log it. The notice and the date it arrived, on the job's register, as four records rather than one email. One record per item, because the answer will be different for each. The ensuite tile might be yours. The downpipe might be the landscaper's. The laundry ceiling is the one to worry about.

Week one, go and look. Your photos, with their capture times, on the same records as the owners'. While you are there, pull up what the register already knows about that laundry: who did the roof plumbing above it, and whether anyone checked the flashing before the ceiling went up. If the register was kept during the build, this is ten minutes. If it was not, this is the week.

Decide each item, with a reason. Defect, not a defect, or not yours. Major defects are covered for six years and other defects for two years from completion, and eight months after handover this house is well inside both. A refusal is fine. A refusal with no reason and no photo is the thing the inspector reads first.

Reply in writing, before day 28. Which items you accept, when the trade will attend, what access you need. Offer dates, and record them. "They would not let us in" is a sentence that helps you only if the dates are on the file.

Fix it so it stays fixed. The trade attends, photographs the finished work, and someone on your side checks it before the item closes. If the laundry stain comes back in February and there is no after photo and no name against the check, you are starting again with less goodwill and a shorter fuse at the Commission.

Where it goes wrong

The usual failure is not refusing. It is the notice sitting in an inbox that belongs to a project that finished in March. The site manager has moved to a job in Torquay. The office forwards it to him, he means to look at it, and on day 31 the owners lodge their claim. Nobody said no. Nobody was asked a question with a number on it.

The fix is boring. Complaints go on the same register the job was built on, with an owner and a date, not into an inbox. In IssuesId each item goes on as a Warranty record against the room, raised by the owner from the project's reporter directory so their contact details stay with it. It is issued to the trade by email with a link that opens the job without a login. The Defect Notification report gives the trade a PDF worded for the cost, with your coordinator's name and signature. The trade cannot mark it complete without an after photo, and cannot close it. Every email the defect sends sits on its history with whether it was delivered or bounced.

What it will not do is make the 28 days longer, or write the reply for you. There is no complaint-notice form in the product and no clock that counts down from receipt. The due date on each item is the one you set. I would set it at day 21.

The scheme, the dates and the sources are on Victoria's building reforms. The short version of this post is what should a builder do with a complaint notice. This is general information, not legal advice; the regulations and the Commission's guidance apply.

IssuesId